Hikaru no Go 9 by Yumi Hotta and Takeshi Obata: A-

From the back cover:
Practicing at Go salons is turning out to be more fun than Hikaru thought. But at one salon he meets his match in Suyong Hong, a sullen 12-year-old who is studying for the pro test in his native Korea. By mistake, Hikaru insults Suyong, and now the only way they can settle their differences is by playing a grudge match!

Review:
This volume picks up where the last left off, with Hikaru and friends playing against adults in various Go salons around town. Through the experience, Hikaru learns valuable confidence, as well as the ability to count points during play and control the outcome of a game to force a tie. These bits are okay, but not very suspenseful.

The match with Suyong is surprisingly enjoyable, even though Suyong is annoying. I liked how the other patrons of the salon really got into the match. The most significant bit, however, is that Kaio’s Go coach happens by and praises Hikaru, comparing his play to that in the first junior high tournament he entered, when Sai was actually dictating the moves. Hikaru is elated, but Sai is worried.

We end up with a couple of chapters devoted to the resumption of the pro test, which is about where I started bemoaning the small amount of pages left, because these bits are so crazily addictive. Akira, who had already shown that he feels Hikaru on his trail, checks the results from home and freaks at Hikaru’s winning streak, accepting a lowly teaching job with another kid in the test just to indulge his curiosity on his rival’s progress.

Although a manga about a board game might seem dull (the uninspired back cover text doesn’t help this impression), this volume disproves that notion when it focuses on the rivalry between Hikaru and Akira and how it fuels each of them to improve. The earlier chapters weren’t bad, but it was the latter half of the volume that was truly exciting. Also, though I’ve seen the anime and know what is coming, I’m still eager to see the plot with Sai play out because it brings a lot to the story.

Bleach 6 by Tite Kubo: A-

From the back cover:
Ichigo Kurosaki may not know this, but the world he lives in is one predicated on balance—between the living and the dead, between everyday life and the Soul Society. Soul Reapers aren’t merely fighting Hollows, they are charged with the grand task of equalizing the balance between this life and the next. Naturally, if too much energy is channeled to one side, really bad things will happen—just as they’re happening now!

Ichigo and Ishida’s competition inadvertently results in generating a leviathan of a Hollow whose sheer size is capable of tearing the Soul Reaper’s delicately constructed balance to ribbons. Is Ichigo Soul Reaper enough to fell this giant and protect the equilibrium of the universe?

Review:
I liked Ishida before, but I like him more after the events of this volume. Oh, sure, his backstory isn’t really anything amazing, but I like how he and Ichigo interact, and how their powers combine in combat. All of the scenes with them together were enjoyable.

The team seems to be just about complete, with a few more having yet to decide whether to acknowledge their abilities or not. I very much like the direction the story is headed in the final chapter, and it is weakening my resolution to hold off a bit on acquiring volume 7.

Bleach 5 by Tite Kubo: B+

From the back cover:
Ichigo Kurosaki thought that Soul Reapers were the only ones hunting Hollows, but he was wrong. Enter Uryuu Ishida, a Quincy, and possibly the last member of a powerful clan that died out over 200 years ago. Unlike Soul Reapers who strive to cleanse Hollows of their sins and send them to the Soul Society, Quincies adopt a more direct approach—they kill Hollows without hesitation. To demonstrate the supremacy of the Quincies’ ways, Uryuu challenges Ichigo to a contest—bait is spread around the city, attracting a large number of unstable Hollows. Whoever defeats the most wins, regardless of the danger.

Review:
Though this volume starts off decently enough, with Ishida issuing his challenge to Ichigo and Rukia learning the history of the Quincies, it’s when the focus shifts to some of Ichigo’s friends and family that things get good. The three chapters featuring Chad and Karin confronting one of the horde o’ Hollows are especially fun, and Tatsuki continues to kick butt (often literally).

Though all of this is certainly entertaining, there really isn’t any plot to speak of. It’s more of a free-for-all. At least the characters go through some changes, even if the story doesn’t advance a whole lot.

Bleach 4 by Tite Kubo: B

From the back cover:
A new reality-show craze is sweeping the nation, garnering legions of screaming fans. But this program comes with a supernatural twist—the host, a media-savvy spiritualist, travels to local hotspots and performs exorcisms, live on national TV! Surly Soul Reaper Ichigo Kurosaki has his doubts about this primetime prima donna, and his assumptions are about to be put to the test—the show is heading straight for his neighborhood. What effect will this unprovoked media presence have on the fragile balance between Earth and the spirit world?

Review:
Remember that meat of the story I thought we’d be progressing to about now? At first, this volume disappointed me, because it seemed that all we’d get was this mini-arc of little significance. Ichigo fights a Hollow at the taping of the flamboyant spiritualist’s show. Wow, surprise. But it eventually became apparent there are some repercussions from this event that will further the story along, so it wasn’t just filler after all.

Speaking of filler, I liked the first chapter about Kon’s search for a more loving owner than Ichigo. I also realized I like every one of the major and supporting characters, with the possible exception of Ichigo’s dad. Rukia continues to be an interesting combination of competent and girly, Ichigo’s sister Karin is possibly figuring some things out, Chad’s love of cute things is awesome, Tatsuki is also really beginning to grow on me as a character (I just love her character design) and Ishida is already a welcome addition.

Bleach 3 by Tite Kubo: B+

From the back cover:
It’s the anniversary of Ichigo’s mother’s death, and the entire Kurosaki clan, along with former Soul Reaper Rukia Kuchiki, head to the cemetery to pay their respects. Sleeping demons rarely ever stay still and pretty soon Ichigo confronts the Grand Fisher, the Hollow that may be responsible for his mother’s demise.

Review:
Ichigo’s fight with the Grand Fisher is your typical shounen fare. What made the whole arc more special were the reactions from Ichigo’s sisters, Rukia, and Kon and some background information provided by Ichigo’s long-time friend, Tatsuki. The pacing of the story is excellent, including a lot of great atmospheric art that sets the mood. It is so easy to imagine the action being animated that I am left with a surprisingly strong desire to check out the anime.

There are a few funny moments, mostly provided by Kon (whom I adore) and reactions to Ichigo’s spastic dad (who, in himself, is kinda creepy). I usually am not amused by jokes where a character suddenly flourishes a random prop from somewhere to make a joke, so was happy to see that when a gag of this type was employed in this volume, the logistics of lugging said random prop around were acknowledged.

In his comments in the beginning of the volume, Kubo states that, with this volume, the introduction of Ichigo has come to an end. This reminds me of Rurouni Kenshin, as several volumes are employed to introduce characters, have a few minor skirmishes on home turf, etc., before launching into the meat of the story. These twenty-five chapters have been well spent— getting everything set as well as totally hooking me!

Naruto 2 by Masashi Kishimoto: B

From the back cover:
Naruto, Sasuke and Sakura have passed the final test to become junior ninja—but now the real challenge begins. Tired of menial tasks, the young ninja ask for a tougher assignment, and find themselves—together with their teacher, Kakashi—bodyguarding a cranky old man from the Land of the Waves. But Tazuna the bridgebuilder is in more danger than anyone realizes: he’s the target of elite ninja assassins, including Zabuza, “the demon,” and our heroes are about to face a trial by fire…

Review:
I’m happy to report that there were no crude gags or nosebleeds whatsoever in this volume. Instead, the team gets a new assignment that, besides having fun ninja battles, opens Naruto’s eyes to a few things. He’d held a very idealistic dream of becoming a ninja leader, without having the slightest idea of what a real battle is like or considering that sometimes a hero must sacrifice their life for the sake of others. I liked that he wasn’t instantly the hero of the conflict.

Sasuke and Kakashi completely steal the show for me. Sasuke is silent and competent, and I like that sort of character. Kakashi is the rational adult with an occasional silly side, teaching the children sternly and fairly, and also completely awesome when he is actually compelled to fight. He kind of reminds me of Remus Lupin. Like… if he were a ninja.

I am glad I gave this series one more try, because the second volume is loads better than the first. The one thing left that bugs me is Sakura’s apparent utter uselessness. I hope she begins to serve some purpose eventually.

Whistle! 2 by Daisuke Higuchi: A-

From the back cover:
Shou Kazamatsuri and his pals finally hit the magic number 11 and that means they’re ready for high-kicking, goal-to-goal soccer action.

Unfortunately, Team Josui’s first game is against the powerhouse private school, Musashinomori. Shou’s crew may have boundless pluck and enthusiasm but do they have the talent to compete with last season’s reigning champions? Maybe not… but this year they have a secret weapon by the name of Tatsuya Mizuno. Not only is Mizuno the best player on Josui’s squad, he’s also the son of the opposing team’s coach. Soccer action and familial complications collide when father and son meet on opposite sides of the soccer field!

Review:
I am really enjoying Whistle!, and would compare it favorably to Hikaru no Go in terms of a sports manga with fun, likeable characters. Fans of the latter would enjoy this. Artwise, it’s kind of similar too, with a variety of faces and character types so that everyone is distinct. That really helps avoid confusion during the games, which are themselves drawn clearly enough that even a soccer neophyte can easily follow what’s going on.

We see a lot more of two characters I really like in this volume. One, Hiroyoshi, is a chubby little kid who loves soccer but is kind of wimpy. He is adorable, especially on pages 46 and 47. I appreciate how he wasn’t forgotten in the chaos of that scene. Another is Satou, a lively kid who brings the bishounen total up to two. His interactions with the serious Mizuno must surely have inspired some slashy fanfic!

Another bonus to Whistle! is that it’s a shounen manga that’s finished, with 24 total volumes, rather than one of those with 35+ and no end in sight. And I’m sure we’ll see all of it before HnG even hits 15.

Whistle! 1 by Daisuke Higuchi: A-

From the back cover:
Banned from his school’s soccer team for being too short, Shou Kazamatsuri decides there’s only one thing left to do: switch schools!

But even a change in scenery doesn’t help the David Beckham wannabe. On campus, he is mistakenly introduced to everyone as a hotshot star athlete. When the truth is revealed, Shou drops out of school to practice on his own.

Alone, the spunky teenager must work twice as hard to make his dreams come true. He wants to play soccer so bad he’s willing to hustle day and night to make it happen.

Review:
I really liked this story. Even though I know there are translation problems with the title (some soccer terms and names of famous pros), they couldn’t prevent the cute art and fun pacing from winning me over. To clarify one thing about the blurb: the title is really not as cracky as it sounds with regard to schools. Shou’s transfer happens before the story begins, and he doesn’t really drop out of the new school so much as skip classes for a couple of weeks while he practices.

Whistle! is obviously a sports manga, but what differentiates it from others I have read is that Shou is actually pretty abysmal to start out. He doesn’t have a bishounen ghost to help him, nor has he won a bunch of tournaments before the manga starts. He simply loves the sport and works very hard to improve.

He has a great, encouraging brother that I like, and the best player on the team (Mizuno) respects his efforts, rather than being snooty about his superiority. It’s all warm and fuzzy without being saccharine, and I was surprised by how into the game I was. I’ll definitely be reading more.

Naruto 1 by Masashi Kishimoto: C+

From the back cover:
In another world, ninja are the ultimate power—and in the village of Konohagakure live the stealthiest ninja in the world. But twelve years ago Konohagakure was attacked by a fearsome threat—a nine-tailed fox demon which claimed the life of the Hokage, the village champion. Today, peace has returned, and a troublemaking orphan named Uzumaki Naruto is struggling to graduate from the Ninja Academy. His goal: to become the next Hokage. But unknown to Naruto and his classmates, within him is a terrifying force…

Review:
Our library has all of the English volumes of Naruto so far, so I thought I’d see what the fuss is all about. Many of the gimmicks were overused or crude or both, Sakura’s love fixation bothers me, and Naruto went from needing a smacking to inspiring his future rival far too quickly, but still… there’s something about this title that makes me want to give it at least one more volume before making up my mind.

It’s not any kind of fondness for Naruto himself, but some of the side characters are likeable or interesting (Iruka-sensei and Sasuke) and I like the ninja academy idea and the glimpses we’ve seen of Konohagakure. It’s a weird mesh of modern and historical design, and I’m curious to see whether they explain how things developed that way in that world. Lastly, there’s occasionally these little bits of omniscient narration that give off a fairy tale, Princess Bride sort of vibe that I like.

There’s potential here. Maybe there’ll be fewer nosebleeds in the next volume.

Bleach 2 by Tite Kubo: B+

From the back cover:
Immediately after checking into the Kurosaki Clinic with a mysterious scar on his back, the muscle-bound Chad goes AWOL. Accompanying Chad is a talking parakeet imbued with the soul of a young boy named Yuuichi. It doesn’t take newbie Soul Reaper Ichigo Kurosaki long to surmise that a Hollow must be involved. By far the strongest spirit he’s faced to date, Ichigo is about to discover that not every soul is bound for the Soul Society, especially if it’s tainted with innocent blood.

Review:
Volume 2 is even more fast-paced and fun than the first, and even though it employs some of the shounen cliches, there’s enough unique world-building to keep me interested. Of course, Ichigo is developing quickly and uber-awesomely, but nobody really harps on this point, so it doesn’t become annoying. One weird thing is how talkative the Hollows are. I’m not used to big hulking monsters (with exploding leech-bombs!) that actually say stuff.

My favorite part of the story continues to be the shinigami system and methods. They receive orders to take out specific Hollows, receive bonuses for eliminating particularly nefarious ones, and can actually use the bonuses as currency to purchase more nifty shinigami equipment. One such gadget featured in this volume is a pill that allows Ichigo to remove his own soul from his body (he has to be in soul form to fight Hollows) when Rukia is not around to do it. His first experience with it provides the material for the last few chapters, which I liked a great deal.

Disclosures in this volume also suggest that life in the Soul Society might not be as rosy as Rukia has suggested. I am really starting to get into this series.