• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Soliloquy in Blue

Manga and Book Reviews by Michelle Smith

  • Home
  • Reading Lists
    • 2002 Reading List
    • 2003 Reading List
    • 2004 Reading List
    • 2005 Reading List
    • 2006 Reading List
    • 2007 Reading List
    • 2008 Reading List
    • 2009 Reading List
    • 2010 Reading List
    • 2011 Reading List
    • 2012 Reading List
    • 2013 Reading List
    • 2014 Reading List
    • 2015 Reading List
    • 2016 Reading List
    • 2017 Reading List
    • 2018 Reading List
    • 2019 Reading List
    • 2020 Reading List
    • 2021 Reading List
    • 2022 Reading List
    • 2023 Reading List
    • 2024 Reading List
    • 2025 Reading List
    • 2026 Reading List
  • Review Index
    • Review Index by Title A-M
    • Review Index by Title N-Z
    • Bookshelf Briefs Archive
    • Let’s Get Visual Archive
    • Off the Shelf Archive
  • About

The Battle for the Castle by Elizabeth Winthrop: B

November 16, 2006 by Michelle Smith Leave a Comment

From the back cover:
As William turns twelve, he wonders if Jason is still his best friend. In the past year Jason has grown a foot taller while William is still a shrimp. When Jason challenges William to “jump the trains,” William is terrified. How else can he prove himself to Jason?

William has the chance when his former housekeeper sends him a magic token that once again takes him back to Sir Simon’s castle in the Middle Ages, this time with Jason. There they face a dangerous army of rats and their gigantic leader.

Once William was a hero in the castle. Now it’s up to him to destroy the rats and save the kingdom in the final battle for the castle.

Review:
As silly a plot as a dangerous army of rats is, this book was actually better than the first in the series. There’s still a Very Important Lesson to be learned (just because one has the sense not to do a clearly stupid thing does not mean that one is cowardly), but it was better handled than the last time, and the story didn’t seem to exist purely for the purpose of elucidating this message.

The character of Jason is interesting because he is so obnoxious, spurring some conflict between him and William. He’s like that clumsy friend you had who asked to hold your… I dunno, precious porcelain unicorn or something and then proceeded to dance around tossing it in the air, ignoring you while you keep telling him to give it back. The way he talks is very odd, though, and reminds me sooo much of a former piano student. He says stuff like, “Don’t worry, old buddy” or “Check out these babies!” I wonder if my student talked the way he did ‘cos he had read this book and made Jason his idol.

My main complaint is how stupid and incompetent the adults in the castle are made to appear. William and Jason end up coordinating defensive plans and giving instructions to guards and soldiers, and it was just too much for my suspension of disbelief.

Filed Under: Books, Children's Fiction, Fantasy

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Recent Comments

  • Michelle Smith on A Bevy of Buffy
  • Brad on A Bevy of Buffy
  • Manga Bookshelf | Morning Manga Spotlight: Antique Bakery on Let’s Get Visual: Speechless
  • Manga Bookshelf | Viz brings Takeshi Obata to NYCC on Let’s Get Visual: Warm-Up Exercises
  • a-yin on Yumi Tamura: Two Artbooks

Copyright © 2011 Soliloquy in Blue · Powered by WordPress & the Genesis Framework