Fire Investigator Nanase 4 by Izo Hashimoto and Tomoshige Ichikawa: B+

Nanase Takamine is a fire investigator, a job at which she not only excels but also approaches with a dogged determination to discover the truth. In this volume, she’s on the case of a fatal fire at the home of an elderly, wealthy man with three suspicious children, and later must determine why an experienced arsonist made a beginner’s mistake.

Nanase is, in a way, haunted by a notorious arsonist called Firebug, who seems to turn up at every crime scene, provides clues that point Nanase in the right direction, and is possibly responsible for the fire that killed her parents seven years ago. Their interactions are the highlight of this series, with Firebug increasingly insisting that Nanase turn to administering vigilante justice, either against arsonists or, more recently, against a detective who seems to know Firebug’s true identity.

Usually, the Firebug scenes overshadow Nanase’s investigations, but the first case in this volume proves more interesting than most, managing to sneak in some character development and surprises with a cast that’s only around for four chapters or so. This improvement, coupled with intriguing glimpses of the detective’s suspicions, means that the fourth volume of Fire Investigator Nanase is its best so far.

Review originally published at Manga Recon.

Twin Spica 1 by Kou Yaginuma: A-

The year is 2024. Fourteen years ago, Japan’s first attempt at a manned space mission ended in disaster, as something went wrong 72 seconds into the flight, causing the craft, “The Lion,” to crash in the middle of a city. The crew, and many civilians, lost their lives. Asumi Kamogawa’s mother was among the wounded, lingering in a coma for five years before finally succumbing to her injuries.

Even so, Asumi grew up with a passionate love of the stars, and spent many hours stargazing with her mysterious friend, a young man—wearing a lion’s-head mask—that no one else seems able to see. As a child, Asumi wasn’t shy about sharing her dream, but lately guilt over leaving her father behind compels her to take the entrance exam to the Tokyo Space School without telling him. When he finds out, Dad proves he’s not so helpless after all, since he’s been working and saving for years in order to be able to make his daughter’s dream come true.

This frees Asumi to continue with the admissions process, the next step of which is a test that requires her to live with two strangers in a room for seven days. This is a fun glimpse at the space school world she’s about to enter, as well as Asumi’s strengths relative to those of her prospective classmates. Physically tiny, she possesses a child-like sense of wonder, which sometimes leads her to ask seemingly stupid questions, but is also able to see patterns in things that others miss. While most of the other candidates fail, Asumi’s team is a success, thanks in no small part to her contributions.

Instead of forging ahead with her promising future, the rest of the volume is composed of short stories—the success of which was ultimately responsible for Twin Spica becoming a series—depicting incidents from Asumi’s childhood and revealing the true identity of her masked friend. The second tale, “Asumi,” in which Asumi dreams she is able to help her mother’s spirit reach its destination, is especially touching. I admit it: I cried. The existence of Mr. Lion, and the supernatural possibilities he introduces into the story, means that this encounter really could have happened, too.

Artistically, Yaginuma’s work is clean and attractive, with lots of white space—as is appropriate for the “closed-off environment adaptability test”—and a variety of panel layouts. The one thing that bugs me is that Asumi looks really, really young throughout. She’s supposed to be smaller than others her age, but she winds up resembling a second or third grader in comparison. I hope this isn’t a hint of moe infiltrating what is otherwise a very fine story.

With this first volume, Twin Spica is just, if you’ll pardon the awful pun, getting off the ground. I definitely look forward to discovering what is to come, and especially appreciate Vertical’s commitment to releasing all sixteen volumes of this series by 2012. I could make another pun here about climbing aboard now, the better to experience the journey, but I’ll spare you.

Twin Spica is published in English by Vertical, Inc. Only the first volume is out so far, but the series is complete in Japan with sixteen volumes. The review copy I received included the following publishing schedule:

Volumes 1 to 4: 2010
Volumes 5 to 10: 2011
Volumes 11 to 16: 2012

Review copy provided by the publisher. Review originally published at Manga Recon.

Fire Investigator Nanase 3 by Izo Hashimoto and Tomoshige Ichikawa: B

From the back cover:
“The Towering Inferno” continues! Nanase and her team are sent into the Astro Tower, a brand new skyscraper that everyone believes to be practically indestructible. But when the anti-fire device system suddenly goes down, there is no advance warning when the boiler blows. Now, Nanase is trapped in the fiery building with all of the terrorists, but the Wolves of Vengeance might not be what they seem. And when people start dying from non–fire-related deaths, there might be a real killer on the loose… but who?!

Review:
The third volume of Fire Investigator Nanase finds our titular heroine trapped in a skyscraper that’s allegedly the target of terrorists. As she tries to work out what’s going on—this series still feels a great deal like Case Closed to me—more fires and explosions erupt inside the building, and with various civilians depending on Nanase to see them to safety, she’s forced to come up with some clever solutions (occasionally with some possibly telepathic help from Firebug, a notorious arsonist who has taken an interest in her) on the spot.

I really want to like Nanase more than I do, since it has such a neat premise, but the fact remains that the culprit here is entirely easy to guess and even indulges in some stereotypically evil cackling after his/her deeds have been discovered. At times, it feels more like a shounen series than a seinen one, but then you’ll get a particularly grisly and random death by fire to remind you that this series is intended for older readers.

I like Nanase okay as a character, though I find her most interesting when she’s interacting with Firebug. The highlight of this volume for me is a scene in which he’s goading her to kill the culprit, even showing her how, but she resists. As the volume concludes, she learns a few things that may forever alter their working relationship. Is the series about to get truly good? I hope so.

Lastly, a note on the art, specifically Nanase’s wildly improbable anatomical proportions. I think if one were to take her measurements, they’d be something like 35-16-17, because her bosoms have at least twice the circumference of her tiny waist. The bosoms play no part in the story, thank goodness, but they are there and fairly distracting in some panels. I guess I should consider it just another concession to the demographic.

Black Cat 12-14 by Kentaro Yabuki: B+

Black Cat may not have the most innovative or sophisticated plot ever conceived—our hero and his friends face off against a mentally unbalanced bad guy and his lackeys—but it’s executed so well and the characters are so likable that I can’t help but be thoroughly entertained each time I consume another chunk of the story.

In volume twelve, Train and friends meet with Dr. Tearju, a nanotech expert who might be able to help Train (now in the body of a child) return to normal. Tearju’s advice enables Train to overpower the nanomachines causing his condition and use them to develop a new power—immediately dubbed the “rail gun”—which essentially allows him to electrify his bullets. Creed’s forces attempt to draft Tearju, and when that fails, they use a monkey with clone powers (I am not making this up) to steal both her appearance and her knowledge. All of this makes Eve decide that the time has come to go after Creed, as he’s much too dangerous to remain free.

Train agrees, and after revealing the story of his past and deciding that he wants to administer justice as a sweeper rather than pursue vengeance as the Black Cat, he sets about acquiring intel on Creed’s whereabouts. While Sven goes off to train his “vision eye,” which allows him to see a few seconds into the future, Train and Eve enter into an alliance with some other sweepers. This is quite a fun twist on things, and the fourteenth volume ends with a (literal) boatload of sweepers making their way to Creed’s island hideout.

There are six volumes left of this series, and if they’re comprised of a huge epic battle between the sweepers and Creed and his goons, I think I could be quite happy indeed. As I said, this isn’t the deepest series ever, but it’s genuinely enjoyable to read and whenever I finish the volumes I’ve got on hand, I always wish I had more. I like that the characters seem to genuinely like each other, too; some of the best moments are things like child-sized Train and Eve going to see a movie called “A Dad and His Dog” together.

Lastly, I rejoice that I have finally gotten an answer about those weird things on Train’s jacket! Tucked away in a character popularity poll was the information I’d been seeking. Yabuki writes that the “donut-shaped accessories on Train’s chest are made of wood with a metal interior. They serve as a sort of shield.” Not that we ever see them function in that capacity, but at least we need wonder no more!

Planetary 1: All Over the World and Other Stories by Warren Ellis and John Cassaday: A-

From the back cover:
This is Planetary: three people who walk the world for strangeness and wonder, uncovering things others wish were left covered. They are the mystery archaeologists, explorers of the planet’s secret history, charting the unseen borders of a fantastic world.

Review:
I loved John Cassaday’s art in Astonishing X-Men, and even I have heard the name Warren Ellis spoken in awe, so a collaboration between the two seemed an excellent choice for continuing my tentative foray into the world of American comics.

First, a confession of sexism. When I first saw the cover, I assumed that the elderly gentleman, replete with gravitas, would be the leader of this three-person team of mystery archaeologists with an “investigative mandate” to seek out the hidden secrets of the world. As it turns out, he (a reclusive and exceptionally long-lived fellow named Elijah Snow) is the newest recruit. The actual leader is Jakita Wagner, the woman clad in skin-tight leather. She’s also completely brilliant, possibly hiding something, and never once objectified as a sex object despite her garb. I approve.

With the third member of their team, an evident technopath and possible nutter who calls himself The Drummer, they investigate matters that come to the attention of the world-wide Planetary organization, which receives its funding from a mysterious source known only as “the fourth man.” Their discoveries are varied, ranging from a super-computer with the ability to manipulate parallel worlds, to an island once populated by monsters, to an interdimensional trading ship that crash-landed on earth millennia ago and just wants to go home. My favorite story, “Dead Gunfighters,” mingles technology with the supernatural in the tale of a betrayed and murdered cop who’s somehow been given ghostly form to seek his vengeance.

The first several tales appear episodic, ending with the attainment of knowledge and not with the team actually doing something with what they’ve learned. This frustrates Elijah a good deal, and perhaps it’s because of his grumblings that the team later takes a more proactive role in the case of some missing astronauts. By this point, links between some of the stories have emerged; it would seem the repercussions of the super-computer’s invention in the ’40s are still being felt in 1999, when the story is set.

In addition to all the plotty goodness, the characters are richly drawn and I find that Ellis’s skill with dialogue has not been overstated. I like that their personalities are distinct, but each remains somewhat of an enigma, particularly where Elijah’s past and his possible connection to an organization that is Planetary’s opposite are concerned. His predecessor’s fate also has not yet been revealed, but I’m sure it’ll come to light eventually. Lastly, I really like how the three characters’ special abilities are revealed organically within the context of the story. There is no silly introduction like, “I’m Jakita and I’m super strong!” “I’m Elijah and I can manipulate temperature!” They just use their talents when they need to and that’s that.

Sometimes, when I read speculative American comics—like Sandman, for instance—I’m strangely depressed afterward. I had the same reaction with Planetary. For all that it is good, it’s also fairly grim and made me ponder things (like humanity’s transient insignificance) that I don’t much enjoy pondering. That said, it’s only four volumes long and I can probably take it in short doses, if it means eventually getting some answers.

Probably.

Adolf 4: Days of Infamy by Osamu Tezuka: A

From the back cover:
While Adolf Hitler continues to wage war on the world and the Jewish people and Japan attacks Pearl Harbor, Japanese reporter Sohei Toge finally falls in love with one of the many women who has fallen for him!

Meanwhile, Adolf Kamil, a Jew living in Japan, befriends the Communist son of a Japanese MP in an attempt to deliver the secret documents about Hitler to a famous spy who will play a major role in the defeat of the Third Reich. But Adolf Kamil’s best friend, Adolf Kaufmann, by now a confirmed Nazi, is sent to Japan with orders to destroy the precious documents at any cost!

Review:
The fourth book in Osamu Tezuka’s outstanding Adolf covers a period of several years in the early forties in which Germany declares war on the Soviet Union and the presence of a Russian spy, Ramsey, in Japan presents Toge and his fellow conspirators with an opportunity to get the papers about Hitler’s Jewish blood into international hands. Most of the volume deals with arranging for the documents to be transferred to Ramsey, though love is in the air, too, as several couples discover feelings for each other. I assume this is Tezuka’s way of saying that even when times are grim, the human heart cannot be extinguished.

While he only appears in the last couple of chapters, the emotional crux of this series for me remains unfortunate Adolf Kaufmann, now a Lieutenant in Hitler’s service. In her forward to this volume, editor Annette Roman describes him as “impressionable,” which is precisely the perfect word for him. He does horrible things out of a real, though misguided, sense of devotion for Hitler, and when he realizes that the Führer has become mentally unstable, it’s a real blow to him. When he dares mention his concerns to another Nazi, the response he gets is basically, “Yeah, we know.”

Another comment Roman makes is that while Adolf can be enjoyed as a simple thriller set against the backdrop of World War II, Tezuka uses this plot to examine every “evil humans are capable of.” That’s especially true with Kaufmann’s plight. Even though he oversees terrible, terrible atrocities, we’ve seen him grow up and we know about his desperate need to prove himself worthy. His acts are evil, but it’s hard to believe that the person is the same. The other Nazis, on the other hand, perpetrate the same cruelties Kaufmann does, but without the idealization of a charismatic leader and deep personal insecurity as an excuse. Is Kaufmann really better than they are? Not ultimately, but he has been humanized by his struggle while they have not.

More turmoil is definitely in store for Kaufmann in the upcoming final volume. Unable to trust Hitler’s judgment, he refuses to obey an order to kill a renowned general pegged by the Führer as having been involved in an assassination attempt against him. For this insubordination, Kaufmann is shipped off to Poland in disgrace. It’s there that he reconnects with Lampe (of the Gestapo), who reiterates an offer he’d made before: go to Japan and destroy the documents and anyone who has knowledge of them. The volume ends on a marvelous cliffhanger as we know what Kaufmann’s mother has been up to in his absence, and how this will tie in with the task he’s been ordered to perform.

One does feel a little guilty anticipating the excitement and drama of the pending conclusion, but it’s a testament to Tezuka’s craft that he’s able to shine a light on inhumanity while simultaneously entertaining his audience.

Bleach 30 by Tite Kubo: C+

From the back cover:
Ichigo and his friends are moving ever closer to the center of Hueco Mundo and rescuing Orihime. But their battles against the Arrancars are testing them in ways they never thought possible. Can they keep their honor in a world where it doesn’t exist, or will Hueco Mundo leave an indelible mark on their souls?!

Review:
Ichigo (who actually appears very, very little in this volume) and friends are still fighting their way toward rescuing Orihime. Chad and his nifty new arm are able to vanquish one foe, but not before another arrives who dispatches him in short order; Rukia encounters an Arrancar who looks exactly like Kaien, her former Assistant Captain, and must figure out what his true motives and origins are; and Renji faces off against a science-inclined Arrancar in a spot where his ability to use his bankai is blocked.

Reading this volume, featuring a gang that has split up and is currently engaged in one-on-one fighting, on the heels of a very similar setup in One Piece invites comparison, and it is not one that Bleach emerges from with the advantage. In One Piece, a sense of place and how the characters’ actions will help achieve the ultimate goal are abundantly clear. In Bleach, partly because we’re in a nebulous realm like Hueco Mundo, there’s really no clear idea of where anybody is, who they’re fighting at this moment, or how any of this is actually getting them closer to Orihime.

Kubo attempts to liven things up by having us believe that a couple of our heroes have died, but I honestly didn’t find any of this compelling in the least. A skewering in One Piece shocked me; a skewering in Bleach makes me go “ho-hum.” Really, the most interesting aspect of this arc continues to be Orihime’s relationship with Ulquiorra, an Arrancar who seems curious about her and humanity in general. I wish more time were devoted to that pairing.

In the end, this installment is somewhat of a disappointment. I wonder if I wouldn’t be better off hoarding Bleach and reading it in chunks rather than a volume at a time; perhaps then I’d be able to get swept up in the momentum and actually care about what’s happening to the characters I’ve followed for 30 volumes now.

One Piece 19-21 by Eiichiro Oda: B+

I had originally checked out about a dozen volumes of One Piece from my local library with high hopes of reading them all in the allotted time, but life intervened and I sadly ended up turning most of them back in. I did, however, manage to read these three volumes, in which the Straw Hats attempt to prevent civil war from erupting in Princess Vivi’s kingdom (Alabasta) due to the devious meddlings of the head of the Baroque Works criminal organization, Sir Crocodile.

In volume nineteen, Luffy and the gang arrive in the town where Crocodile, thought to be a good guy by the townspeople, is living, and some of them are very promptly captured. We learn more about the rebels in Alabasta—and how all they’ve really wanted is for the king to prove that he hasn’t done the dastardly thing Crocodile has pinned on him—and this volume succeeds in making the country’s troubles much more compelling than I found them to be in the previous batch of volumes I read.

As the rebellion heats up, Crocodile gives Vivi the choice of rescuing her friends or attempting to save her country. Sanji arrives at a timely moment and proceeds to be a fabulous badass for about a panel, before eagerly asking Nami, “Do you love me now?” After rescuing the navy captain who’d attempted to capture them, the group heads for the palace in Alubarna, where the rebels and royal forces are set to converge within hours. Luffy is recaptured by Crocodile, but insists that Vivi and the others carry on without him. Vivi’s reaction to Luffy’s devotion to her cause is quite touching, and is another example of a member of the group learning to trust the others and let themselves be helped.

While volume nineteen features a lot of good character moments, volumes 20 and 21 are chiefly devoted to fighting, as the Straw Hats split up to draw away the Baroque Works agents and give Vivi a chance to make it to the front. First, Luffy faces off against Sir Crocodile, culminating in an awesomely shocking skewering; Usopp and Chopper (whose delight in being of use is extremely sweet) take on the slow-witted Mr. 4 and his partner, Miss Merry Christmas; Sanji engages in a particularly memorable encounter with Mr. 2 Bon Clay; Zolo faces off against Mr. 1, whose body is made of steel; and Nami tries out a new weapon in her fight against Miss Doublefinger. It’s particularly nice to see Nami obtain some combat prowess at last, and it feels like forever since we’ve seen Zolo in action, too.

Although I don’t generally like the battles as much as the rest of One Piece, Oda handles them so skilfully I can’t help but be impressed. There are multiple events going on here in multiple places, but one is never confused for the slightest moment. Everything is paced well, the reader knows where everyone is at any given moment, thanks to some handy maps, and we’re reminded of what’s going on in other places just frequently enough to reinforce the epic scale of what’s going on. Lines like “Their hopes are about to collide at Alubarna” elevate the skirmishes beyond mere displays of Devil Fruit powers and again exemplify why this series is a shining example of shounen manga.

Although the civil war situation is not resolved by the end of volume 21, matters are definitely coming to a head, though it might still be a couple of volumes before this arc concludes. The temptation to check out another huge chunk of this series is strong, and it’s possible I won’t be able to resist it, but I shall at least attempt to get to the next few volumes in a timely manner this time!

Itazura Na Kiss 2 by Kaoru Tada: B+

One could easily expend five hundred words or more relaying all the ups and downs contained in this double-sized volume of Itazura Na Kiss, but the most important facts are these: Kotoko and Naoki graduate from high school and move on to attend the same college, where Kotoko’s attempts to fit into Naoki’s world generally meet with embarrassing results. They also share a single, somewhat spiteful, kiss, and various events lead Kotoko to proclaim her intention to give up on Naoki, just in time for a renewal of close proximity that makes this impossible to achieve.

This series is a fine example of a romantic comedy that puts equal emphasis on both factors. Not that Kotoko’s relationship with Naoki is romantic yet—he is still too mean to her for that to be true—but there are quite a few comedic scenes in which the two leads do not appear at all that serve to further flesh out the setting and supporting characters. The least amusing of these tend to feature Kin-san, a persistent classmate who carries a torch for Kotoko, while the best revolve around Naoki’s mother, who is an avid supporter of a relationship developing between Kotoko and her son.

Though it can be a little painful to observe the desperate floundering of people in love, the end result is a story that’s consistently entertaining. Even after consuming 300+ pages in one sitting, I still wanted more.

Review copy provided by the publisher. Review originally published at Manga Recon.

Cute Devil by Hiro Madarame: C

Girly-looking Fuuta Naruse has many male devotees at school, but the only guy he has eyes for is Tohru Akiyoshi, the aloof class president who has not joined his throng of admirers. Fuuta exerts all his wiles in a confession to Akiyoshi, but when that doesn’t work, he sheds the cute persona and declares, “I’ll just have to take you by force.”

And so it goes. Akiyoshi is frequently violated and humiliated by Fuuta, but can’t confide in anyone about it, because nobody would believe him. Occasionally, he attempts to grow a spine and at one point tells Fuuta, “What you’re doing is a downright crime…” but, of course, he goes all doki doki at the next opportunity, and eventually begins fantasizing about their encounters. In the end, after Fuuta experiences an unprecedented growth spurt over summer break, he does one nice thing for Akiyoshi and now we’re supposed to believe he’s an okay guy.

Ordinarily, I’d give a book like this a lower grade, but Madarame’s art is seriously cute sometimes and provides a much-needed element of levity. I’d love to see what she could achieve with a better concept featuring more likable characters. In fact, I’d love to see Hisashi, Fuuta’s hulking and adorably dim-witted bodyguard, star in a vehicle of his own. He was easily the best thing about this one.

Review copy provided by the publisher. Review originally published at Manga Recon.