• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Soliloquy in Blue

Manga and Book Reviews by Michelle Smith

  • Home
  • Reading Lists
    • 2002 Reading List
    • 2003 Reading List
    • 2004 Reading List
    • 2005 Reading List
    • 2006 Reading List
    • 2007 Reading List
    • 2008 Reading List
    • 2009 Reading List
    • 2010 Reading List
    • 2011 Reading List
    • 2012 Reading List
    • 2013 Reading List
    • 2014 Reading List
    • 2015 Reading List
    • 2016 Reading List
    • 2017 Reading List
    • 2018 Reading List
    • 2019 Reading List
    • 2020 Reading List
    • 2021 Reading List
    • 2022 Reading List
    • 2023 Reading List
    • 2024 Reading List
    • 2025 Reading List
    • 2026 Reading List
  • Review Index
    • Review Index by Title A-M
    • Review Index by Title N-Z
    • Bookshelf Briefs Archive
    • Let’s Get Visual Archive
    • Off the Shelf Archive
  • About

Honey and Clover 5 by Chica Umino: B+

July 15, 2009 by Michelle Smith 3 Comments

honeyclover5From the back cover:
Takemoto is nearing graduation, but he doesn’t have a job lined up—he doesn’t even know what he wants to do with his life. His friends try to be supportive, but they have their own dramas to act out. With his health failing and his heart in turmoil, how will Takemoto find the strength to carry on?

Review:
I unreservedly adore the cover of this volume. Colorful whimsy is the way to get me every time, I think. Alas, I don’t have such effusive praise for the actual contents.

There’s nothing overtly bad. In fact, there is quite a bit that is good, including the truly excellent first chapter. Mayama quits waiting for Rika to make a move and, nudged along by his coworkers, manages to reinstate himself in her employ. He refuses to let her push him away and resolves that he’s going to eventually extinguish her wistful thoughts about joining her late husband on the other side. Later, Yamada receives marriage proposals from five childhood friends and finally understands how Mayama felt receiving a love confession from someone he cared about but only on a friend or sibling level. Lastly, Takemoto works himself into exhaustion and comes to some personal realizations—like the fact that through it all, Hagu was close by, watching over him—just in time for Morita to return.

What bothers me is that some of the attempted humor, mostly involving Morita, is just sooo over-the-top that it’s not funny. There are a few times when someone gets injured and a joke is made about calling the ambulance, but it’s hard to tell what’s an actual injury and when it’s only in jest. There’s a nurse who enforces hospital rules violently. There’s Morita’s surprising appearance at the Mocademy Awards and his subsequent acceptance speech/rant. It’s all just really… crazed. Even Morita gets some nice moments, though, like when he takes care of his drunken advisor after finally managing to graduate.

One humorous episode, though, was truly amusing. Takemoto’s graduation piece, a somewhat lopsided tower, confuses the judges until Professor Hanamoto gives it a title—Tower of Youth—and then suddenly the judges are teary-eyed, going on about youthful ambitions and vulnerabilities. Although the title wasn’t Takemoto’s idea, he does later decide that the tower represents himself and his aimless state, and destroys it, beginning anew on a new tower that represents his decision to stay in school one more year and find out what it is he really wants to do with his life.

All in all, definitely not a bad volume. Just a rather hyper one.

Filed Under: Josei, Manga Tagged With: Shojo Beat, VIZ

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Danielle Leigh says

    July 15, 2009 at 8:02 am

    I mostly read this title for Takemoto I think…I relate to him (which probably isn’t a good thing, I suppose). Otherwise, can we drown Morita? Most. Annoying. Character. Ever.

    Reply
    • Michelle says

      July 15, 2009 at 9:54 pm

      I can’t quite hate Morita, because he does have his good moments—particularly where consideration for Yamada’s feelings is concerned—but if there’s anything I dislike about a volume you can be sure that he (or Mayama’s irritating bosses) is behind it!

      Reply

Trackbacks

  1. Twilight reax and SDCC highlights « MangaBlog says:
    July 16, 2009 at 7:10 am

    […] Phil Guie on vol. 1 of Higurashi When They Cry: Cotton Drifting Arc (Manga Recon) Michelle Smith on vol. 5 of Honey and Clover (Soliloquy in Blue) Ysabet Reinhardt MacFarlane on vol. 6 of Honey and Clover (Manga Life) Ysabet […]

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Recent Comments

  • Michelle Smith on A Bevy of Buffy
  • Brad on A Bevy of Buffy
  • Manga Bookshelf | Morning Manga Spotlight: Antique Bakery on Let’s Get Visual: Speechless
  • Manga Bookshelf | Viz brings Takeshi Obata to NYCC on Let’s Get Visual: Warm-Up Exercises
  • a-yin on Yumi Tamura: Two Artbooks

Copyright © 2011 Soliloquy in Blue · Powered by WordPress & the Genesis Framework