The Daughter of Time by Josephine Tey: A

daughtertimeFrom the back cover:
Confined to a hospital bed, Scotland Yard’s Inspector Grant is engrossed with a portrait of Richard III. How is it possible, he wonders, that such a sensitive-appearing soul could have been the odious villain, the Wicked Uncle responsible for the murder of his own nephews to secure the British crown for himself? Grant reconsiders 500-year-old evidence and brilliantly arrives at a compelling new answer to one of the most intriguing mysteries in history: who really murdered the Princes in the Tower.

“For truth is rightly named the daughter of time, not of authority.” – Sir Francis Bacon

Review:
After an embarrassing accident, Inspector Grant faces an extended convalescence in a hospital bed. Helpfully minded friends have dropped off some novels, but they hold no appeal. It’s only when Grant’s friend Marta, knowing his interest in faces, brings by a selection of historical portraits that the irksome prickles of boredom begin to fade. Particularly captivating is the portrait of Richard III, whose sensitive expression speaks more of illness and suffering than the villainy for which he is chiefly remembered. His police instincts roused, and together with a research assistant (also supplied by Marta) to do the necessary leg work, Grant sets about proving whether Richard III really did murder his nephews as history claims.

Ever since reading Sharon Kay Penman’s The Sunne in Splendour, I’ve had an interest in Richard III and, if pressed, would count myself among those who believe in his innocence. The Daughter of Time comes to the same conclusion, eschewing the hearsay accounts that fill the history books—often penned by historians from the Tudor years who did not like to write too favorably about the Plantagenets—in favor of contemporary sources and, when that isn’t available, a basic understanding of human nature. Taking it one step further, Grant examines the question of who had the most to gain by the princes’ deaths, and ends up making the case that Henry VII was ultimately responsible.

The wealth of historical information required to make these points is presented in a way that’s anything but dry; on the contrary, I found it fascinating. What makes The Daughter of Time so great, though, is that the storyline in the present is also fun. In what other novel does the protagonist spend the whole of the book confined to bed, his mind challenged and engaged but his body immobile? Anyone who ventures into Grant’s room is liable to be subjected to questioning on the topic of Richard III, and indeed, it’s a member of the hospital staff whose change in opinion regarding the much-maligned monarch is the first triumph of the inspector’s efforts.

Now that I’ve read something so pro-Richard, I feel the need to achieve a balanced view by reading an account that casts him as the murderer. Look, therefore, for a review of Alison Weir’s The Princes in the Tower in the near future.

Comic 7 by Ha SiHyun: B

comic7The series that began with a heroine determined to learn more about the art of creating manhwa has now completed its transformation into a high school romance drama. Rather than reference Alice Song’s career goals in any way, this volume is full of sports festivals and love confessions.

On the heels of a particularly nasty fight, Alice and Patrick, the boy she loves, are fuming as the sports festival begins and end up partnered to different people for the three-legged race. Alice, determined not to let Patrick see how upset she is, is all smiles in the company of her smitten partner, Neil, and inspires him to risk his health in order to win the race. Patrick angsts a good deal about how happy they look together, and though he makes efforts to better get to know the scheming girl who’s been relentlessly pursuing him, he still can’t give up on Alice. Nor can she give up on Patrick, despite the fact that Neil has confessed his feelings to her. The volume ends with both of them out on the streets on a rainy night, trying and failing to connect.

“Trying and failing to connect” is the story of Alice and Patrick’s relationship in a nutshell, and one of the most interesting things about this volume is seeing how different Alice is in each boy’s company. Neil and Alice seem to mesh easily; with him, she shows a calm and gentle side that Patrick has not been privileged to see. When Alice and Patrick are together, on the other hand, quarrels are frequent and emotions intense. As far as love triangles go, this is definitely a compelling one; it keeps me invested in reading the series even though it’s strayed from its original concept.

Review copy provided by the publisher. Review originally published at Manga Recon.

Comic 1-6 by Ha SiHyun: B

comic1When a friend of amateur manhwa-ga Alice Song enters Alice’s story in a contest, she ends up taking third prize. Upon meeting with the publisher, she runs into an old student teacher (now working as an editor) who takes her to meet one of her favorite creators, Saturn Kang. Saturn turns out to be a rather arrogant high school boy who wants none of Alice’s help, even though he’s cutting it close for his deadline. They butt heads a lot, and this relationship extends into the high school realm because, of course, Saturn (whose real name is Patrick) is the studliest guy at his all-male school and all the girls at Alice’s neighboring all-female school are crazy for him.

comic2Alice has talent, but her work is unrefined, and after realizing just how much she doesn’t know, she decides to formally apply to be Patrick’s assistant. He’s reluctant at first, but her passion and willingness to perform menial chores wins him over and he begins teaching her in earnest. When the corporation funding Alice’s school goes bankrupt, the two schools merge and Alice and Patrick begin to see each other more often. With the merger, Patrick also comes to the attention of Daria, a scheming frenemy of Alice’s, who soon resolves to make him hers and generally causes a lot of strife for our protagonists. Though Patrick has been nursing feelings for Alice for a while, it’s the situation with Daria that prompts Alice to finally realize that she likes him, too. They both resolve to confess their feelings at Daria’s upcoming birthday party.

comic3Matters come to a head in volume five which, despite employing a pretty massive misunderstanding plot, is still the best of the series so far. Both leads have been duped by Daria in different ways, but seem to’ve finally made their feelings for each other clear, only for Daria’s scheming to intrude again. By the end of volume six, each is stubbornly sticking to his/her guns, with Alice demanding an apology for something she witnessed and Patrick demanding that, just this once, she actually believe him that he hasn’t done anything wrong. Meanwhile, Patrick’s best friend, Neil, returns from a long convalescence and develops an interest in Alice without knowing she’s the girl Patrick likes. There’s a great scene where each boy describes her in completely different ways, and swear that no girl could ever come between them.

comic5Comic is an entertainingly addictive series, but I stop short of calling it a truly good one. It begins well, with Alice declaring that she doesn’t want a normal life and with some fascinating excursions to manhwa specialty stores and details on the craft of comic-making. There are signs, though, that reader desires might’ve nudged the series in another direction. The character of Mr. Hwang, for example, Alice’s old student teacher and original love interest, is suddenly shipped off to Taiwan with very little fanfare. Then when the school merger occurs, the cast of students expands to include attractive obstacles in the path of Alice and Patrick’s relationship. Gradually, manhwa is mentioned less and less frequently until volume six, where it doesn’t come up at all. The series seems to’ve completed its metamorphosis into your standard angsty high school romance drama. Not that there’s anything inherently wrong with that, but one wonders where all of Alice’s passion and drive went.

comic6Though I grumble a little about the evolution of the series, it nonetheless provides some good moments and memorable characters. Early on, Patrick shows a surprisingly sensitive side when he doesn’t let on how abysmal Alice’s “help” has been and listens when she expresses her sorrow that her old school building, site of so many memories, will likely be condemned. And while Alice has a tendency to be hot-headed and run away from arguments, I like that there’s sometimes no clear right and wrong in their fights. Their conflict in volume six is a great example, as each has a valid point that they won’t back away from. Unfortunately, it seems much could be solved if they would only communicate better; a story that relies so much on misunderstandings is always a frustrating reading experience for me.

Ultimately, Comic is a fun and quick read that would be perfect for a romance fix. As long as you don’t go into it expecting the insights about manhwa to last, it should be a sufficiently enjoyable experience.

Review copies for volumes four and five provided by the publisher.

Bleach 29 by Tite Kubo: B-

bleach29From the back cover:
Ichigo and his friends knew invading Hueco Mundo wouldn’t be easy, but even the lesser Arrancars are pushing them to their limits! Can Ichigo, Uryuu and Chad find the inner strength to overcome the first line of attack, or will Orihime be stuck in Hueco Mundo forever?!

Review:
When you get right down to it, nobody does anything in this volume but fight. Ichigo, Uryuu, and Chad all face Arrancar opponents and each is pushed to employ the hidden reserve of strength they’d hoped to save for higher-level opponents. I’m enough of a shounen fangirl that I enjoy it when characters power up, so this volume is fun on that score, at least.

We begin with Ichigo, who is fighting some kind of Latino Arrancar who keeps needling him to reveal his bankai move. Once he’s witnessed that, he demands to see Ichigo’s Hollowfication skills, but alas, he only gets to enjoy it for about a second before he’s done for. Uryuu’s opponent is difficult enough that he’s forced to use some awesome kind of sword/arrow thing that finishes her off easily. And Chad, who always seems to get the short end of the stick in this area, not only reveals a new form of his powerful (defensive) right arm but suddenly unveils that the left one has (offensive) powers too.

I know, I know, this is not manga craft at its finest, but when I saw Chad’s left arm I swear I literally said “Aw, cool!” aloud. There’s definitely a kind of satisfaction to be derived from watching our battered heroes suddenly whip out a surprise weapon or tactic and go all badass on their foes. It may not be deep, but it can be awfully entertaining.

Review copy provided by the publisher.

The Gentlemen’s Alliance Cross 10 by Arina Tanemura: C

gentlemen's10After resolving some convoluted-sounding subplots involving Haine’s family—featuring maternal amnesia, uncertain paternity, and mansions afire—The Gentlemen’s Alliance Cross moves into the home stretch as Haine is pressed to finally choose between the identical twins with whom she is in love. Alas, just when she finally grasps the idea that the nice twin (Takanari) is probably a better choice than the scheming git (Shizumasa), he’s captured by his brother’s minions and imprisoned. Like any self-respecting shojo heroine, Haine vows to rescue him.

Being the penultimate volume of the series, volume ten offers a variety of dramatic moments and revelations, including arranged marriages, envelopes with surprising contents, and a tale of childhood betrayal that explains the current animosity between the twins. My favorite, though, is the surprise leukemia.

The end product of all these dire events tumbling one atop the other can be described as little else than a mess, and I was much more compelled to snicker at the ridiculous developments than sympathize with anyone involved. Still, I was pretty impressed by how easy it was to jump in and follow the story at this point and ended up liking Takanari, too, though I must question his taste in girls.

Review copy provided by the publisher. Review originally published at Manga Recon.

Skip Beat! 19 by Yoshiki Nakamura: B+

skipbeat19The famous Japanese native turned Hollywood actor, Koo Hizuri, is in town and Kyoko has been assigned to wait on him throughout his stay. He’d originally planned to treat her cruelly in order to elicit a rise from Ren, but can’t fight the temptation to polish the “uncut diamond” of Kyoko’s talent. As a result, he ends up giving her an assignment—create and enact the role of his son, Kuon—and develops a paternal bond with her while helping her to discover her main weakness.

Readers are aware that Kuon is actually Ren, and when Ren runs into Kyoko-as-Kuon, it’s not long before he requests a meeting with the father he hasn’t spoken to in five years to demand an explanation. Ren’s past has been a mystery throughout the series, and it’s a delight to finally get more details. We come to understand Ren better, past and present, and though there’s clearly more yet to be disclosed, what we get here is still satisfying.

Lastly, I appreciate that Koo isn’t portrayed as a self-aggrandizing stereotype but is actually kind and likable. He joins Lory, the president of the talent agency, and Sawara, Kyoko’s manager, in the roster of fun middle-aged men in the cast. That’s just one of the many quirks that make Skip Beat! so unique and worth reading!

Review copy provided by the publisher. Review originally published at Manga Recon.

Skip Beat! 15-18 by Yoshiki Nakamura: B+

skipbeat15I had no idea it’d been an entire year since I’d read any Skip Beat!. At least my procrastination produced an appealing side effect: a nice little stack of volumes to catch up on!

Volume fifteen finds Kyoko shooting on location for the TV drama in which she and Ren are cast. Sho happens to be staying in the same hotel, since there’s also a ritzy recording studio nearby, and is being challenged by a band called Vie Ghoul (awesomely referred to by Kyoko throughout as “Beagle”) who has already stolen one of his songs. Reino, the psychic vocalist of Vie Ghoul, decides that it’s not enough to mess with Sho’s career; he’ll also mess with Kyoko, aiming to usurp Sho’s place as the object of her fixation.

skipbeat16This plotline has repercussions through volume seventeen. Though I don’t like Reino at all, he’s an incredibly good catalyst. The fallout from his actions includes:
– Sho protecting Kyoko from Reino. I love that her reaction is anything but docile gratitude.
– Kyoko helping Sho recover from the song theft by informing him that he can’t lose to anyone but her.
– Ren getting angry that Kyoko kept the Reino drama from him, and an awesomely awkward reconciliation ensues.
– Delicious scenes between Sho and Ren in which they push each other’s buttons in extremely entertaining ways. This includes Ren interrupting when Sho is about to confess his feelings to Kyoko (who is still insisting that no thanks for his actions is required; his saving her now only makes them even).
– Glimpses into Ren’s violent past.
– Some small and sweet progress between Ren and Kyoko, including his wonderfully adorable reaction when she tells him that his presence gives her courage and confidence. (This, in turn, leads to amusing teasing from his manager, Yashiro.)

skipbeat17 Pretty impressive, no? I could expound upon each of these points at great length but would no doubt still fail to capture just how terrific they are, especially the interactions between Sho and Ren. I have no idea how I came to enjoy Sho so much, but he’s really grown on me. Also worth praising is Kyoko’s defiance of shoujo convention: instead of being weepy and contrite when Sho rescues her, she’s furious and humiliated to have been protected by her nemesis; and instead of accepting Ren’s offer of protection, she says that his presence gives her the strength to fight back herself. Focused on her goals and seeing neither man as a romantic prospect, Kyoko is a breath of fresh air.

By volume eighteen, she’s back in Tokyo. The Dark Moon drama has begun airing and offers for more roles are coming in, but the problem is that they’re all for characters like the one Kyoko plays in Dark Moon. Moko advises her to turn them all down because accepting them won’t get her anywhere while Sho, boosted by Kyoko’s efforts, is currently setting records and dominating the charts. The famous actor Kyoko’s waiting on as a Love-Me Section assignment, however, advises her to take them all and challenge herself to play each one differently. In order to work on her ability to create characters, he challenges her to recreate the role of his son, Kuon. Readers realize that Kuon (aka Corn) is actually Ren, but Kyoko, as in most things, is oblivious. Volume eighteen’s good, and I like that the actor isn’t the jerk he seemed to be at the start, but I’m more interested in where these events will take the story, rather than in the events themselves.

skipbeat18Skip Beat! has many qualities that I love in manga, particularly its warmth, humor, and fiercely independent heroine. There are, though, a couple of things about it that bug me. The first is how the narration of a character’s inner thoughts often spans multiple pages while they’re actually engaged in doing something else. I often find myself reading ahead just to complete a thought and then going back and reading the rest, which gets annoying. Secondly, I’ve always believed that any kind of physical effect from Kyoko’s “grudge demons” was purely a comedic gag, but in one of these sidebars, Nakamura states that Kyoko’s actually capable of causing paranormal phenomena, and later, Reino’s psychic abilities come to the fore when he can detect Ren’s past ownership of Kyoko’s beloved lucky stone and also sees flashes of his past. I’m not sure I like the introduction of these elements into the story, but thankfully they don’t seem poised to occupy too much attention.

I’m torn between declaring that I’ll never let so much time lapse between volumes of <Skip Beat! again and advising others to stockpile volumes to read as I have done, since the accumulation of awesome is greater the longer one is privileged to inhabit this special world. In either case, this series is highly recommended.

Flashforward by Robert J. Sawyer: C-

It’s possible that this review contains spoilers for FlashForward the TV show, but unless the show plans to alienate viewers by being really, really boring, I rather doubt it. Still, proceed at your own risk.

flashforwardFrom the back cover:
A scientific experiment begins, and as the button is pressed, the unexpected occurs: everyone in the world goes to sleep for a few moments while everyone’s consciousness is catapulted more than twenty years into the future. At the end of these moments, when the world reawakens, all human life is transformed by foreknowledge.

Was that shocking revelation a peek at the real, unalterable future, or was it only one of many possible futures? What happens when a man tries to change it, like the doctor who has twenty years to try to prevent his own murder? How will the foreknowledge of a part of “then” affect the experience of the “now”?

Review:
I expect that this book is seeing a resurgence right now, with people curious to see how it compares to the action-packed show that began airing on ABC this fall. Actually, though, there’s not much similarity between the two properties. The TV show retains the basic idea of a phenomenon that causes all of humanity to catch a glimpse of their future, a character who sees nothing at all and begins investigating his own murder, and the name Lloyd Simcoe, though it’s (seemingly) been applied to a very different man. All of the rest—the myriad debates on theoretical physics, lengthy and detailed descriptions of scientific research facilities, the questions of culpability—has been expunged, and it’s a decision I fully support.

I am far from knowledgable about science, so you won’t get any arguments from me on the feasibility of events and their explanations as they appear in the novel. Even if the science is dodgy, I accept it as poetic license necessary to get the protagonists to ponder certain questions. On one topic I do feel qualified to call foul, however, and that’s the deplorably facile depiction of relationships. I’ll give you an example. Lloyd’s fiancée, Michiko, has a daughter who is killed when the flashforward occurs. Never do we actually see Lloyd experiencing grief. No, he just thinks a lot about how much he loved and how grieved he is to lose “little Tamiko.” He never simply calls her by name; it’s always “little Tamiko.” Funny how adding one word can make a person sound so insincere.

Which leads me into my second gripe: the author seems to have a disdain for non-beautiful women. At first, I thought it was just Lloyd. In his vision twenty years hence, he’s lounging in bed with a woman in her sixties. His 45-year-old consciousness immediately dubs her a “hag” for having had the temerity to age and later, he describes the gait of a heavyset woman as a “waddle.” A couple of other guys eventually get in on the act, though, with one describing a young woman’s 40-year-old future self as “hardly a hag” (as if it were possible for a 40-year-old woman to be one!), which he intends as a compliment, and another insulting older women again with the term “crone.” The one female character of any significance, Michiko, is beautiful and allegedly brilliant, though we never see her actually do anything brilliant. Instead she cries a lot and tries to convince Lloyd to marry her even though his vision shows him with someone else.

About the one part of the novel that’s genuinely interesting is the investigation into a murder that hasn’t happened yet. It’s not that Theo, the scientist who didn’t see a vision, is a particularly compelling character, but that the dash of mystery provides welcome respite from dry technobabble and Lloyd’s point-of-view. Unfortunately, the dead weight of the rest of the novel begins to drag even this storyline down and somehow manages to make what should be an exciting moment—a chase scene involving guns, bombs, and hovercarts—into an interminable scene of excruciating dullness.

All of the various plot threads wrap up neatly at the end, and I won’t spoil it by revealing how or why the flashforward occurred. I will say, though, that I will be very, very surprised (and also very bored) if the TV show uses the explanation given in the book. If all the science bored even a nerd like me, it’s definitely not going to play well with the American public at large.

Vampire Knight 1-4 by Matsuri Hino: B-

vampireknight1The first memory Yuki Cross can remember happened ten years ago when she was five: she’s attacked by one vampire but saved by another, the beautiful and pureblooded Kaname. Kaname brings the human girl to the home of a human he knows and his frequent visits throughout her childhood result in her growing very attached to him. Six years later, the introduction of a boy named Zero, sole survivor of a vampire attack against his vampire-hunting family, diverts Yuki’s attentions from Kaname somewhat, since she’s compelled to try to cure Zero of his misery and hatred. When Yuki’s adopted father decides to open Cross Academy as a way to foster peaceful relations between humans (the day class) and vampires (the night class), the three central characters attend, with Zero and Yuki serving as the disciplinary committee (tasked with keeping the peace as well as the secret about the true nature of the students in the night class) and Kaname as the main draw for the vampire contingent, since it turns out purebloods inspire devotion amongst their brethren.

vampireknight2Yuki still carries a torch for Kaname, even confesses to yearning for him, but she’s also very protective of Zero, especially when she learns his secret: as a result of the pureblood’s bite he suffered as a child, he’s turning into a vampire. What’s more, vampires that used to be humans are fated to go insane, at which time they’re hunted down by the vampire elite. Yuki, in earnest shoujo heroine fashion, declares that she will not let this happen and offers Zero her blood so that he may satisfy his cravings without preying on others. Kaname isn’t keen on this arrangement—uttering the gem of a line, “I can’t keep my composure when my dear girl has been pierced by someone else”—and knows he should rightly be preparing to hunt Zero down, but looks the other way because Zero’s the only one in the day class who could protect Yuki if danger should ensue. Aside from the introduction of the vampire responsible for killing Zero’s family, this is essentially where matters stand at the end of the fourth volume.

vampireknight3Thus far, Vampire Knight is an exceptionally pretty bowl of angsty soup that offers a sprinkling of legitimately good scenes amidst a broth of cheesy and/or eyeroll-inducing ones. Yuki is a big problem, since she is completely and totally ineffectual. She’s one of those types who’ll rush headlong into a dangerous scene, usually intent on helping, and make matters worse by getting attacked or having her anti-vampire gun plucked from her grasp within two seconds of her arrival. She’s got a special weapon—the Artemis Rod—and occasionally demonstrates feats of athletic prowess, but proves incapable of saving herself time and time again. One wonders why on earth this dismally dim girl has two hot vampire boys competing for her affections.

The boys are somewhat more compelling, though not exactly likable. Zero is perpetually unhappy and often sour in disposition, though Yuki’s fretting on his behalf occasionally inspires brief displays of affection. I don’t begrudge him his angst—he is turning into the thing he hates, after all—but his seemingly constant vampireknight4dilemma about whether to give up or try to keep living for Yuki’s sake doesn’t do much for me. Kaname, for his part, is refined yet inscrutable. Even dialogue like, “I can’t bear losing you. Ever.” doesn’t manage to convince me that he’s in any sort of real emotional turmoil. The enjoyable flashbacks in volume three help somewhat to establish his connection with Yuki, though not greatly.

And yet, Vampire Knight possesses attributes that make it not only readable, but also somewhat of a guilty pleasure. For one, the art is very lovely, with bishounen eye candy galore. It’s slathered with screen tone, something I don’t normally like, but that ultimately works well in cultivating a gloomy and oppressive mood. Too, Hino occasionally creates scenes of surprising sexiness and drama, like the first time Zero drinks Yuki’s blood or the shocking final pages in volume four. This series may be blatantly silly at times, but as long as my (awesome) local library continues to carry it, I’m likely to keep reading.

InuYasha 41 by Rumiko Takahashi: B

inuyasha41In the past few volumes, it’s begun to feel like the final confrontation between Inuyasha and the evil Naraku is drawing nigh. First, however, Inuyasha and friends must defeat Moryomaru, a living demonic armor constructed by and to protect the scheming infant that houses Naraku’s heart. Unless the heart is destroyed, Naraku will never truly die. Naraku, for his part, wants Moryomaru dead, too, and is seemingly content to let his enemies fight each other without getting involved.

Moryomaru absorbs powers from other demons to increase his offensive and defensive capabilities, so he’s a tough opponent. Luckily, Inuyasha has just acquired a handy new power for his sword, but it’s one that he’s having trouble controlling. Still, if he’s to have any chance at all against Moryomaru, he might have to use it.

Pretty much this entire volume is about Inuyasha trying to master his sword’s new power while Moryomaru causes a reanimated turtle demon to wreak havoc. Later, the gang and their goodish allies reunite to beat on Moryomaru for a bit, but he escapes. For fans of the series, this actually qualifies as progress, but even speaking as someone who really likes InuYasha, I rather doubt anyone else would enjoy starting here.

Review copy provided by the publisher. Review originally published at Manga Recon.