Hana-Kimi 17 by Hisaya Nakajo: B

From the back cover:
As the giant track meet approaches, Mizuki and Sano face an assortment of foes: Sano’s old high-jump rival Kagurazuka and Sano’s own little brother Shin! But Shin’s trainer is the one man Sano hates the most: his own father. Can Mizuki mend the rift in Sano’s family? While Sano focuses on winning, one person is focused only on Mizuki: Nakatsu, the other boy who loves her…

Review:
This volume was pretty good, though I was annoyed by stuff that wasn’t related to Sano’s family or the romantic triangle. There was a whole random segment on dodgeball and at least three repetitions of a gag wherein a character’s stomach grumbles audibly. Funnily enough, it failed to amuse me each time!

Not a lot progresses in either front, though the way has now been paved for Mizuki to bring about a touching family reconciliation. She also came to the realization that Nakatsu makes her feel safe. Of course, there’s no conceivable way I believe she’d choose him over Sano, but I liked seeing them together at the end of the volume. I’m looking forward to seeing what transpires when Nakatsu learns the truth about Mizuki’s gender. I hope he is furious.

There were some good panels in this volume, particularly of Angry!Sano, and some important moments between the leads (especially the last ten or so pages), but overall, it just felt like a treading water sort of volume.

Hana-Kimi 16 by Hisaya Nakajo: B+

From the back cover:
Sano’s little brother Shin returns! Shin has become a rising star of the high jump, and he’s determined to prove himself by beating his older brother. But that’s not the only blood on the track… the one coaching Shin is their father! Can Mizuki just sit back and watch as Sano fights the father he turned away from… and the brother who never forgave him for doing so?

Review:
The blurb for this volume is misleading, since Sano’s dad doesn’t make an appearance until the last page of the final chapter. His influence over Shin does majorly preoccupy Sano this volume, though, since the dad has a history of pressuring his kids.

The romantic momentum does suffer a little with a plot more focused on Sano’s family, but it’s not completely abandoned, and I thought the balance worked well. I’d still like to see more of the actual high jump competition, but using it as a backdrop for Sano to express his brotherly concern also works for me.

I’m still not sure whether Nakajo has an actual plan for the ending of the series, but I appreciate that things no longer feel as pointlessly episodic as they did around volumes 11 and 12. Maybe she’s gotten better at integrating relationship progress with her random ideas. In any case, I’m happy to be truly enjoying the series once again.

Hana-Kimi 15 by Hisaya Nakajo: A-

From the back cover:
Unable to forget her near-kiss experience, Mizuki finds herself drawing ever closer to Sano, and not in a “roommates” way, either. The tension builds when Nakatsu asks Sano point-blank: Do you like Mizuki? Can Nakatsu and Sano’s friendship survive the answer? Meanwhile, Sano’s old high-jump rival returns, along with a surprising new challenger!

Review:
This entire volume focuses on the love triangle between Nakatsu, Sano, and Mizuki, and that is why it’s so good. Nakatsu learns that Sano does indeed like Mizuki, and struggles with this knowledge for a bit. All of the pining and sighing and leaning one’s head back against a wall that the boys engage in is very entertaining.

Somewhat less successful is the segue back into Sano’s high jump career. I’m glad to see its return, but this is a little clunky, with a few long-forgotten supporting characters making random reappearances and stuff. And, of course, the identity of the “surprising” new challenger is not at all a surprise.

My only worry going into more of the high jump focus is that we’ll lose the relationship momentum that’s been building for a few volumes.

Hana-Kimi 14 by Hisaya Nakajo: B+

From the back cover:
Plumbing problems erupt in Dorm 1, forcing the residents to move into Dorms 2 and 3. Mizuki must now deal with two male roommates, one of whom introduces her to a dorm custom she could never have imagined! Dr. Umeda reflects on his past after hearing from an old friend, while Mizuki and Sano find their mutual attraction pulling them ever closer to the brink!

Review:
Mizuki and Sano get a new roommate for a week. And apparently it’s a tradition in the jocks’ dorm for them to simply walk into the bathroom where their roommate is bathing and begin scrubbing their back. Um, okay. And of course, Mizuki stupidly leaves the door unlocked and has a brush with discovery.

I can forgive some of the goofiness of this plot because it prompts Sano to get annoyed with Mizuki’s carelessness, and try to caution her without revealing that he actually knows her secret. They almost smooch, and after some avoidance and awkward apologies, the plumbing gets fixed and new roommate guy goes away, leaving them alone again.

My favorite part of the volume is the three-part side story about Umeda’s past. We get a little more elaboration on his character (he’s foul-mouthed and complains, but deep down really enjoys taking care of people) and also learn he’d already accepted his sexuality by the time he was a freshman in high school. Therefore, he’s able to recognize his growing love for Ryoichi without angsting about the attraction to a male classmate. This whole tale was sweet and a bit sad, and frankly better than the bits with the main cast.

Despite the implausible elements in the first half, this is definitely one of the strongest volumes of the series in a while. I’d happily read more about Umeda and Ryoichi, and it seems like we might finally be on the verge of progress in the Mizuki and Sano relationship.

Hana-Kimi 13 by Hisaya Nakajo: B

From the back cover:
Mizuki is broke, so she lands a part-time job with Akiha, the photographer. Among her first-day experiences: spilling tea on male diva supermodel “Alex.” This sparks a mutual animosity that is not assuaged when Mizuki discovers the model’s most closely guarded secret! Meanwhile, at Mizuki’s school, food is disappearing, with the culprits leaving flowers in place of what they’ve heisted!

Review:
A little over a year ago I said I wouldn’t be buying Hana-Kimi anymore. Turns out I lied.

The first four chapters in this volume comprise the arc with the cranky model, which in itself is not very interesting until chapter 71. Within this storyline, Mizuki freaks out over the discovery that everyone seems to have a dream for the future except her, providing the opportunity for Sano to be really sweet and reassure her. In fact, there are several cute scenes between them in these chapters. It also seems that we might be seeing more of Sano’s high-jumping soon, which I’d enjoy.

The last two chapters mainly revolve around side characters. I didn’t like Chapter 72 much (the one about the snack thieves), but 73 was quite good. It’s a flashback to Kayashima and Nakatsu’s first days as roommates, and how Nakatsu succeeded in drawing Kayashima out socially and stuff.

Not a lot happened to further the story along, but I didn’t expect it, so it wasn’t as annoying as it has been in the past. I don’t know about absence making the heart grow fonder, but it does seem to’ve grown more tolerant of the episodic nature of the story.

Ouran High School Host Club 8 by Bisco Hatori: A-

From the back cover:
The first-years in Class 1-A are taking part in a test of courage, where the loser will receive the dubious honor of being dubbed “Best of Cowards.” Kazukiyo Souga, the class president and a fraidy-cat at heart, is happy to be on a team with the levelheaded Haruhi, but will he be able to stomach the antics of his other teammates—the twins Hikaru and Kaoru Hitachiin?

Review:
The first story in this volume involves a test of courage, which is really not very interesting in and of itself, though it does bring up again the feelings of the twins for Haruhi. The next episode is about how Kyoya and Tamaki first met in junior high and eventually decided to start the Host Club. It’s cute and fun, and I liked it a lot.

The rest of the volume (three episodes) is devoted to a story about a tough-looking yakuza heir called Kasanoda. Kasanoda (nicknamed Bossa Nova) unintentionally scares off people he wants to befriend and comes to Mori for tutelage. This story did not interest me much at first, but got much better as it progressed.

As the Host Club seeks to interrupt perceived flirting between Kasanoda and Haruhi, Kaoru is led to present an insightful hypothesis (much to Hikaru’s surprise): Tamaki pretends the Host Club is a family in an effort to keep the relationships they all have now from changing.

I normally don’t care much for episodic manga, and if there weren’t enough suggestions of impending developments on the relationship front, I think all the comedy and cuteness in Ouran would wear thin. This volume did a good job combining all the elements into a consistently entertaining whole.

Ouran High School Host Club 7 by Bisco Hatori: B+

From the back cover:
Hunny’s little brother, Chika, pays a visit to the Host Club—and immediately starts attacking Hunny, using all his martial-arts prowess against his older brother! Chika seems to be the absolute opposite of his sweets-loving, Bun-Bun-toting sibling, but why is he so angry with Hunny? The Host Club is determined to find out the cause…

Review:
This volume as a lot more consistent than the last, unified by the theme of Haruhi is contemplating the wall that she feels separating her from the other members of the host club. Learning some of the family backgrounds of the others might gradually be helping her make progress in understanding them.

The first story is about Kyoya in a commoners’ store, and is quite cute. He looks especially nice in his casual clothes, and I love the panels where he’s rummaging in his pockets for money or a cell phone. The chapters about Hunny’s brother were better than I expected them to be, and also reveal how Tamaki lured Hunny from the karate club to the host club. Insight into the twins comes from a tale about their first time crying in public.

Rounding out the volume are a pointless chapter about Roberia Gakuen and a fun bonus story in the “Love Egoist” saga, continuing the tale of the cold-blooded teacher and the student who fancies him.

Ouran High School Host Club 6 by Bisco Hatori: B

From the back cover:
The school festival opens at Ouran, and the Host Club members are busy entertaining the visiting parents. Teasing his son is a favorite pastime of Tamaki’s doting father, the school chairman, but Tamaki’s grandmother is cut from a very different cloth. She despises and shuns Tamaki, banning him from the main Suoh Mansion. It’s now time for Kyoya to take action with the Host Club to help their favored leader out.

Review:
The first few chapters aren’t very interesting or amusing, though they do provide a bit of background on Kyoya’s home life. The last chapter is also fairly pointless. Chapter 26, however, was a good one. We learned more about Tamaki’s family, and how it’s actually a fortunate thing that he is so upbeat and energetic.

The art also seems to’ve changed a little bit. I noticed several times that characters shown in profile had virtually no noses; one even kinda looked like Voldemort! Tamaki and the twins looked a little different, too, though I can’t exactly pinpoint how. I realize it’s normal for art styles to evolve over the course of a title, but this isn’t an improvement.

Ouran High School Host Club 5 by Bisco Hatori: A

From the back cover:
Haruhi’s top ranking falls and she is in jeopardy of losing her scholarship at Ouran. Each member of the Host Club scrambles to become her tutor, but Haruhi picks a female student, Ayame, to help her. Haruhi’s time is now spent with Ayame, who can’t stand Tamaki. Can Tamaki charm his way into Ayame’s good graces so the Host Club can spend time with their favorite member?

Review:
The synopsis above relates only to the first chapter in this volume, which I liked, but it’s the chapters taking place in Karuizawa over summer vacation that are truly wonderful. Not only is the story just cute in general, the twins get a lot of fleshing out, both how they operate together when alone as well as their individual personalities. I never disliked them, but now I’m far more fond of them than before. And more than that, I’m appreciating each one as a distinct, separate character rather than as a unit. Nifty nifty.

The final chapter is alright, I suppose. I didn’t like the little girl at all and actually, when this bit was animated I suspected it might be random filler invented for that purpose. It’s that ho-hum, and is only really worth it for Tamaki and Nekozawa. Now I’m a little worried about what volume 6 will bring. This manga has demonstrated its ability to be awesome; keep it up!

Lastly, I must mention the cute little side panels about the Host Rangers, assigning each club member a color and silly special attacks that they can perform. My favorite: the twins’ “Irresponsible Beam!”

Basara 19 by Yumi Tamura: B+

From the back cover:
Sarasa is engaged in a naval battle with the Royal fleet, but dolphin suicide torpedoes are being deployed against her Shikoku allies to devastating effect. Hiiragi’s assassins infiltrate Sarasa’s Suzaku flagship as she and her crew are pushed to extremes. (Spoilery sentence omitted.)

Review:
If you’re like me, you got about half a sentence through that and went, “… Dolphin… suicide torpedoes?!” Alas, it was just as dumb as it seems. It wasn’t the only slightly lame plot device, either. I think in a few spots Tamura-sensei must’ve just needed something to happen and contrived to make it so, no matter how clunky the result.

Quite a few important or significant things happened in this volume. I only hope I’m able to remember them when volume 20 comes around, as I continue to be fuzzy on details of things that happened only a volume or so ago. It doesn’t help that sometimes things happen so suddenly that one is kind of puzzling how it got to that point so quickly.

Shuri doesn’t appear much, and when he did, it made me realize how much I’ve missed seeing him. He and Sarasa need to reunite soon, durnit, but I like how Tamura handles some of the complications of that event arising.